|
It takes a long time to understand the great Russian writers (or Russians in general,) and Tolstoy is one of the hardest to understand. She read it in three days after school and could discuss every part of it. I lived in Russia six years and am still involved in Russian business after seventeen years. I wanted to see what he wrote after his two big novels, said by many to be the best novels ever written. These stories are good if you see this great writer as a man in transition of thought. Enjoy.Frederick R. I gave "Walk in the Light and Twenty-Three Tales" to a 10-year old Russian girl in Los Angeles. I love the children's book "Three Questions" by Jon Muth based on Tolstoy's short story in this collection.
He recognized God as Love, an understanding that permeates Jesus' healing mission and carried on for years until, as Tolstoy points out, the priests took over. He was excommunicated in 1905 for preaching his brand of freedom--the date of the first great Russian revolution. He was unique in his individual passage out of Orthodoxy. You have to consider the author's evolving frame-of-mind, the atmoshere of approaching revolution. A Russian saying is "Born Russian, born Orthodox," but Tolstoy rejected that, saying the "the Kingdom of God is within you" rather than behind the iconostasis in one of those beautiful but confining churches. These stories, in simple forms, express his individuality. Subtly or not, that is what seeps though his tales. Andresen, Author of "Walking on Ice, An American Businessman in Russia."
He was different only because he understood that everything that the infinite source created was created with love. He thought hard after a long period of struggle and developed a concept of Christianity that many feel makes sense. Jesus was not God; he was as human as other people. It reminds the reader of the Roman emperor with this name who lived between 331 and 363 C.E.
There are essentially two characters in what is basically a parable, a homily, a sermon. Therefore, he also understood that if people want to relate to the source, God, as they should, they can only do so by being like God, showing love to all people. The name is unintentionally ironic because Pamphillius despised everything related to Greek culture.Pamphillius has a friend named Julian. Because they do not focus on Tolstoy's ideas about Christianity, but about proper behavior: that people should help one another.
His son is cheating him of his money. Walk in the Light is Tolstoy's dramatization of what he considers the proper Christian way of thinking. Isaiah 2:5 states: "Come house of Jacob, and let us walk in the light of the Lord." I John 1:7 reads: "But if we walk in the light, as he is the light, we have fellowship one with another."Readers of this tale and some of the other short stories in this volume need to know something about Tolstoy's mindset, specifically his view of Christianity, in order to understand what he is saying and why he said it. He feels totally alone. They simply have their own superior being motivate the proper behavior.
Pamphillius' name is Greek and means "beloved of all." Tolstoy probably assigned him this name because Pamphilius' life goal was love. His wife is now dead. Leo Tolstoy (1828-1910) is known for his novels War and Peace and Anna Karenina and is considered to be one of the greatest novelists. Does Pamphilius have any concern about the future of the universe. He meets Pamphillius by chance several times and the two discuss the teachings of Christianity. The novella was composed in 1893, after he resolved the crisis.
Although successful, he is not altogether satisfied with his life; he feels that something is lacking. Additionally, he despises the concept of private property, but takes advantage of what people provide him and sells objects that he owns.Julian points out that the Christians believe that if people do not "quarrel, nor yield to lust, nor take oaths, nor do violence, nor take arms against another nation" they "will be happy." But, he argues, they miss the point, it is the government and laws that assures, or at least tries to assure that people do these things. Here lies the weakest part of Tolstoy's tale. While Walk in the Light has twenty three other short stories, we will focus our attention on the captioned novella.Tolstoy had a spiritual crisis when he was fifty years old, around 1878. The Roman law and army is protecting him and assuring that he can live in peace. The Christian, Pamphilius, is portrayed as a meek, passive, uneducated and unsophisticated man totally uninterested in improving himself or society.
However, Walk in the Light is best understood as Tolstoy's attempt to put flesh on the bare bones of his notion of Christianity. Why. The ideas that were presented were wrong for, among other things, Jesus was not involved with unnatural miracles. It is a very shallow tale and a disappointment. He has lost his influence in town and the officials in Rome refuse to help him.
Tolstoy believed that God, who he called "the infinite source of being," is not involved in current human affairs. These twenty-three tales are excellent. He also wrote short stories. This "source of being" created everything out of love. Thus, while a zealot today may insist that his wife wear a veil and disfiguring clothes to disguise her beauty from others, Pamphilius does so to hide her beauty from himself. After rejecting Christianity all of his life, Julian is now old. Julian's father pays for Pamphillius to attend school with his son, but Pamphillius leaves school before completing his education to live the life of a Christian.Julian continues his education and after a period of sowing his oats, settles down, marries, has children, and becomes a successful merchant after his father's death.
But the Christians, by removing themselves from the law "under the pretext of living a better life, destroy all that has improved or does improve it." What would happen to society, Julian asks, if everyone would "run away." Furthermore, one of the primary duties of parents is to educate their children so that they can be successful in life, which they neglect. We suppose that our Father has already provided for that. This name is appropriate. In his The Gospel in Brief and other writings, Tolstoy tells how he became convinced that Jesus' teachings were perverted by the people who transmitted them.
"You must train them to be worthy servants of their country." Instead of teaching the children how to improve themselves, they teach them to be withdrawn and passive to "accept either fate (life and death) with equal indifference."Pamphilius' answer does not persuade his friend, "we live in the light and therefore our life does not depend on the body." What was it that caused Julian to accept Pamphilius' life". The title is in the Hebrew Bible and the New Testament. (O)ur law reveals to us that every lustful look at a woman is a sin, and so we and our women, instead of adorning ourselves to stimulate desire, try to avoid it that the feeling of love between us between brothers and sisters, may be stronger than the feeling of desire for a woman which you call love.Pamphilius tells Julian that he seeks happiness; but while Julian wants honor and wealth, he finds happiness in "submissiveness.in giving everything up."Julian criticizes his friend, saying in essence that while he is segregating himself from society and despises Roman laws and its army, he is taking advantage of the many benefits that society provides. and was viciously opposed to Christianity.The two friends grew up together in Tarsus, in the south of modern Turkey, about a hundred years after the onset of Christianity.
His views should be respected, but this novella fails to do his views justice. The group is so concerned about the problems of lust, that they make their wives ugly to diminish their love for them and make their relationship no higher than the love between a bother and his sister. Walk in the Light contains a novella called Walk in the Light While There Is Light, with a subtitle A Story of Early Christian Times. Everyone has a right to believe as he or she feels fit. His depression led him to Pamphilius.In his introduction to Great Short Works of Leo Tolstoy, which does not contain this novella, John Bayley writes: "It is a mistake to regard the writings of Leo Tolstoy too much in the light of a sage's personal utterances rather than as works of art." Certainly this is true as a general statement. It isn't.
Our aim is simply to live in accord with His will.What about marriage. Since love is paramount among Pamphilius' group, one would think that marital love should be emphasized. Tolstoy felt that he understood the true concept of Christianity. The story does not depict Pamphilius' ideas well and it offers a very weak reason for Julian to accept his way of life.Boomer Books released the Twenty-Three Tales by the same translators in 2006, but they deleted Walk in the Light. Julian is the son of a rich merchant and Pamphillius of a freed slave. Remarkably, Tolstoy answers "No." Pamphillius tells Julian:It is true that we do not set ourselves the aim of continuing the human race, and do not make it our concern in the way I have heard your philosophers speak of it.
Tolstoy is no exception. While all of these twenty-three tales focus on the proper Christian life, it is interesting to note that all religions have versions of these stories.
This is a book of very short stories (except for the first one, which is 60 pages or so). "The Imp and the Crust" was another interesting story, about how a devilish imp gets an honest farmer to sin is to increase his harvests.The stories are generally short and simple ways of illustrating an idea. Each of them has a point to make about morality or Tolstoy's brand of Christianity. Some of my favorites were "The Three Questions," in which a king tries to figure out the most important time, the most important people, and the most important actions, and "Where Love Is, God Is," which gives an example of the "Whatever you did to the least of these" passage in Matthew 25. They're not what you'd call great, complex literature, but I enjoyed the depth behind them. They aren't stories you read and forget about-- several of them give you something to think about even after you set the book down.
Clearly these stories are not appropriate for children, despite the claim of the book. No way to get that claim out, but I would not be reading these stories to my children or allowing my children to read this book. Even at my ripe old age of 71, I cannot fathom the author's intention for young people to read this collection.
I was already a huge fan of Leo Tolstoy: reading Resurrection (my favorite book), The Kingdom of God is Within You, A Confession, Gospel in Brief, and Great Short Stories. This book is also incredible and full of more light-hearted and inspiration stories. They are simple and carry much moral and theological depth to them. It seems that they would be perfect for children and adults alike: for any of those who wish to see the Gospel message in the light of service towards fellow man and God in love.
|
